What is an Arbitration Agreement?

What Defines an Arbitration Agreement?

An arbitration agreement is a contract in which two or more parties agree to resolve disputes through a private arbitration process instead of pursuing litigation in court. In arbitration, a neutral person (the arbitrator) decides the case instead of a judge or jury. It’s usually faster, private, and less formal.

What Is Arbitration?

Arbitration is a dispute resolution method where disagreeing parties present their cases to one or more neutral third parties, known as arbitrators, instead of going to court over contract compliance issues. Unlike litigation, which often involves lengthy court proceedings, public records, and rigid procedural rules, arbitration offers a more flexible and private approach to conflict resolution.

In arbitration, the appointed arbitrator or panel listens to evidence and arguments from both sides before deciding to resolve the dispute. This process typically moves more quickly than court proceedings and follows less formal rules. The arbitrator's decision, called an "award," is usually final and binding on all parties involved, meaning it can't be easily appealed or overturned.

Read on to learn the key elements of this agreement, the different types, its advantages and disadvantages, and how to create one.

• What Defines an Arbitration Agreement?
• What is an Arbitration?
• Key Elements of an Arbitration Agreement
• Purpose of an Arbitration Agreement
• Types of Arbitration Agreements
• Advantages of an Arbitration Agreement
• Disadvantages of an Arbitration Agreement
• Common Uses of Arbitration Agreements
• How to Create an Arbitration Agreement
• How Icertis Enhances Arbitration Agreement Management

Key Elements of an Arbitration Agreement

An arbitration agreement should contain several critical components that define how disputes will be handled and resolved. Here are the key elements you'll find in any arbitration agreement example. Use them to help you craft an effective and enforceable mutual arbitration agreement:

Agreement to Arbitrate

The core of any arbitration agreement is the explicit commitment from all parties to resolve specified disputes through arbitration rather than litigation. This section clearly states that the parties waive their right to bring covered disputes to court, including jury trials, and agree to submit them to arbitration instead.

The language must be clear and unambiguous to ensure mutual consent and prevent enforceability challenges later.

Scope of Disputes Covered

This element defines which types of disagreements fall under the arbitration process. Some agreements broadly cover "all disputes arising from or related to" the underlying contract, while others specifically state covered disputes or exclude certain matters.

This section should be carefully drafted to avoid ambiguity about which conflicts require arbitration and which might still be litigated.

Selection of Arbitrator(s)

The agreement outlines how arbitrators will be chosen, whether by mutual agreement, from a specific organization's roster, or through another method. It may specify the number of arbitrators, required qualifications, subject matter expertise, or standards of neutrality.

Arbitration Rules and Procedures

This section establishes the procedural framework that will govern the arbitration process. It often references established rules from organizations like the American Arbitration Association (AAA), Judicial Arbitration and Mediation Services, Inc. (JAMS), or the International Chamber of Commerce.

These rules cover everything from initial filings and arbitrator selection to evidence presentation, hearing procedures, timelines, and award issuance. The agreement might also include modifications to standard rules to fit the parties' specific needs.

Venue and Location

The agreement specifies where the arbitration proceedings will take place. This could be a physical or virtual location. The venue choice affects convenience, cost, and which laws apply to certain procedural questions.

For international agreements, venue selection is crucial because of varying enforcement standards across countries.

Cost and Fee Allocation

This element addresses how arbitration expenses will be shared or allocated between parties. Costs typically include arbitrator fees, administrative expenses, hearing facility charges, and attorney fees, if applicable.

The agreement might require that costs be shared equally, allocated to the losing party, or handled through an alternative arrangement. Cost provisions can impact access to the arbitration process, especially for parties with limited resources.

Confidentiality Clause

Many arbitration agreements include provisions maintaining the privacy of proceedings and outcomes. Unlike court cases, which create public records, arbitration can offer confidentiality for sensitive business information, trade secrets, personal data, or reputational concerns.

The agreement specifies what information must be kept confidential, who is bound by the confidentiality, and the potential consequences for breaching the contract.

Language and Governing Law

For clarity and proper interpretation, agreements specify the official language for proceedings and which jurisdiction's laws govern the arbitration agreement and the underlying dispute.

Understanding the governing law prevents misunderstandings and establishes a clear legal framework for addressing contractual interpretation questions or procedural issues that are not explicitly covered in the agreement.

Enforceability of Arbitration Awards

This section confirms that arbitration decisions are legally binding and enforceable. It often references applicable laws, such as the Federal Arbitration Act or the New York Convention, which provide for the judicial enforcement of arbitration awards.

This element establishes the authority of the arbitration process and clarifies that parties must comply with the arbitrator's final decision.

Types of Arbitration Agreements

Arbitration agreements come in several forms, each of which you should know if you plan on using them in your business.

Binding vs. non-binding:

Most arbitration agreements are binding, so the arbitrator's decision is final and enforceable. Non-binding arbitration, where parties can reject the outcome and opt for litigation, is more of a structured contract negotiation

Mandatory vs. voluntary:

Mandatory arbitration requires parties to use arbitration for covered disputes, whereas voluntary agreements offer arbitration as an option that parties can choose after a dispute has occurred.

Pre-dispute vs. post-dispute:

Most arbitration agreements are made before any dispute arises (pre-dispute), typically within the original contract. Less commonly, parties may agree to arbitrate after a dispute emerges (post-dispute agreement).

Administered vs. ad hoc:

Administered arbitration follows the rules and procedures established by institutions like the AAA, while ad hoc arbitration operates under procedures specifically created for that dispute, without institutional oversight.

The type of arbitration agreement significantly impacts how disputes are resolved and the parties' legal rights.

Advantages of an Arbitration Agreement

Arbitration agreements offer several benefits compared to traditional litigation, including:

• Efficiency and speed: Arbitration typically resolves disputes more quickly than court proceedings, which can take years to conclude. With simplified procedures, limited discovery, and greater scheduling flexibility, parties often reach final resolutions in months rather than years.
• Privacy and confidentiality: Unlike public court records, arbitration proceedings remain private, protecting sensitive business information, trade secrets, and reputational interests. This confidentiality can be valuable for disputes involving intellectual property, executive employment, or high-profile parties.
• Expertise in complex matters: Parties can select arbitrators with specialized industry knowledge or technical expertise relevant to their dispute. This contrasts with court litigation, where judges may lack specific expertise in the subject matter of the case.
• Procedural flexibility: Arbitration allows parties to customize procedures to fit their specific needs. This might include modified discovery processes, tailored evidence rules, or hearing formats that are suitable for specific industries or types of disputes.
• Lower costs: While not always less expensive, arbitration often reduces overall costs through faster resolution times, limited discovery, and more streamlined proceedings compared to full-scale litigation.

Disadvantages of an Arbitration Agreement

Despite their clear benefits, arbitration agreements have potential drawbacks that businesses should consider, such as:

• Limited appeal rights: Arbitration decisions typically have minimal grounds for appeal compared to court judgments. This finality can be problematic if an arbitrator makes errors of fact or law that significantly impact the outcome.
• Potential arbitrator bias: Although arbitrators are supposed to be neutral, concerns exist about "repeat player" bias, where arbitrators may favor businesses that frequently use arbitration services. This perception can undermine confidence in the fairness of the process, especially in consumer or employment contexts.
• Discovery limitations: The streamlined discovery process in arbitration may prevent parties from obtaining all relevant evidence. This can disadvantage the party with less access to information, potentially affecting the outcome of the case.
• Costs for initiating proceedings: While arbitration can be less expensive overall, initial filing fees and arbitrator costs may be higher than those for court filings, potentially creating access barriers for individuals or small businesses with limited resources.
• Enforcement challenges: Although arbitration awards are legally binding, enforcing them sometimes requires additional court proceedings, which can add time and expense to the process.

Common Uses of Arbitration Agreements

Arbitration agreements appear in various contexts, including both business and consumer relationships. A few common use cases include:

Employment contracts:

Employers often include arbitration clauses that cover workplace disputes, discrimination claims, or termination issues. These agreements have become increasingly common across industries and job levels.

Consumer agreements:

Arbitration provisions often appear in terms of service for products, credit cards, banking services, and online platforms. Consumers often accept these agreements when making purchases or using services.

Commercial contracts:

Business-to-business arrangements typically include arbitration clauses for handling disputes related to performance, payment, quality issues, or contract interpretation.

Construction agreements:

Due to the technical nature and potential for disputes in construction projects, arbitration agreements are often included in contracts between property owners, contractors, and subcontractors.

Healthcare services:

Many healthcare providers incorporate arbitration provisions in patient agreements to address potential malpractice or service quality disputes.

International business:

Cross-border commercial relationships commonly use arbitration agreements to avoid navigating multiple court systems and to ensure consistent dispute resolution procedures.

In all of these cases, proper contract lifecycle management ensures that arbitration agreements are properly drafted, reviewed, approved, and monitored throughout their entire lifespan, helping businesses maintain control over their dispute resolution processes while minimizing legal risks.

How Icertis Enhances Arbitration Agreement Management

The Icertis Contract Intelligence Platform helps businesses create, manage, and enforce arbitration agreements more effectively. By bringing all your agreements into one digital system, Icertis provides better visibility and control over how you handle disputes, while ensuring compliance with changing laws and regulations. Our contract management software eliminates the headaches of tracking paper documents and spreadsheets, putting everything you need at your fingertips.

Icertis offers smart features like standardized clauses, risk alerts, and obligation tracking, which help legal teams maintain consistent arbitration provisions across the company. With our contract intelligence platform, businesses reduce the likelihood of entering into unenforceable agreements and resolve conflicts more smoothly when they do arise.

Request a Demo